nekare: (Default)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] nekare at 02:48pm on 22/07/2007 under , ,
I've spent a ridiculous time writing this review, mostly because I kept on being distracted by checking the newest wank at F_W and laughing at all those people that actually lit green candles with roses to Snape prvious the release. Er, no offense if anyong who reads this actually did that, it just sounds incredibly hilarious XD (also, it appears that the Harmonians are wanking under flock, isn't it? Too bad, they've always been awfuly entertaining.)

- The first chapter was incredibly creepy. Sure, there was not that much emotional resonance with the murder of what-was-her-name teacher, but it doesn't matter -- it's the tone of the chapter that matters, the way it's just dark and unrepentant and doesn't allow any hope.

- The Trio. I want to draw hearts around them. ♥ ♥ My favorite part of the book was while they were in hiding, apparating desperately with no food and no idea where to go and wanting to throttle each other while they could do nothing to help the crumbling Wizarding world. There was such a sense of isolation and desperation in all that part - it felt war-like, bleak, oppresive, and I loved it. Them being proactive and getting into the Ministry and Gringotts (aw, my ickle little spies, they're so awesome, even if their plans are somewhat dodgy sometimes), it was just so awesome.

Ron leaving broke my heart a bit, but I do think it fits with his character - he's too rash, sometimes, and I'm sure all the time he spent looking for Harry and Hermione were hell on him and his conscience. Besides, his return was so so incredible that I don't mind one bit. The Ron/Hermione, too, was just lovely, very well told, in my opinion. In any way, I just loved how the tension level was so high - it really kept me at the edge of my seat all through it (especially because it was so fast-paced and there was so much action all the time) with my heart beating wildly.

- Remus. I've heard a loooot of criticism about him and while in a way, I agree (he did act in a pretty rotten way) I don't really think it was completely OOC, he's always had a huge inferiority complex and he's never been the charming and saint-like person fanon has made him to be. I dunno, I've always found him very human, and being afraid and wanting to run are very human things to do. In any way, I'm mostly sad that he didn't take his last chance of happiness but well, the Remus/Tonks was treated incredibly badly. I don't really mind it per se, it's just that if they had at least looked happy, it'd made their deaths far more resonant. And really, poor Tonks, she was such an amazing character reduced to a pregnant lady on the sidelines calling out for her runaway husband. Boo. BUT seeing Remus all enchanted with his kid did make up for it a bit. Especially his shouted 'HERE, I HAVE PICTURES!!' XDD In the end, I'm just glad he's happy in the afterlife. He's always been my favorite character, though, and oh, Remus John Lupin, it's been such a ride. ♥

- NEVILLE AND LUNA KICKED ASS. Especially Neville, oh my, he went HARDCORE, YO, and fought Death Eaters with PLANTS. SO MUCH LOVE. ♥ And that's another part of the book I liked - the Battle of Hogwarts, in which everyone was a hero and amazing and McGonagall SICKED DESKS ON THE BAD GUYS and Trelawney THREW MAGIC BALLS ON GREYBACK and Ravenclaw proved to be THE COOLEST HOUSE EVER. I kinda wanted to hit Harry for a while because he wouldn't. remember. about the. diadem. That and him not figuring out Ron and Hermione had gone to the Chamber of Secrets. But all is well. (er, no pun intended?)

- Man, it was a bloodbath! o_O Fred I'm still mourning, Tonks died innecessarily, Lupin was probably intended to die all along although it's still quite tragic and, surprisingly, it was Dobby's burial and his epitaph what made me cry the hardest. Heart-breakening, all of it.

- I'm kinda meh at the whole 'Harry was a Horcrux!' and the 'Snape was in love with Lily!' But I don't mind it that much. I liked Dumbledore's backstory and him and Grindelwald are so very OTP. ABERFORTH FOR THE WIN. AS SO IS GRAN LONGBOTTON.

- All of the mentions of the Marauders were, of course, pure WIN. Sirius and his muggle bikini-clad girls! Lily writing about how Harry had nearly killed the cat! The photo! *happy sigh*

- The Malfoys. People are complaining (but really, when have they not?) about Draco not redeeming himself in the end and blah blah blah. I, for one, found it perfect - The Malfoys are really in just for themselves, and the fact that Lucius and Narcissa really do care about his son more than they do about anything else doesn't negate the fact that they're horrible persons that have killed and maimed and lied. They're pretty selfish, and JKR shows it very well.

- Albus Severus Potter and Scorpius Malfoy. *dies laughing* Yes, they are awful, awful names (AS/S, LOL LOL LOL), but really, what can we expect from the woman that decided that Bilius would make a dashing middle name?

(I've heard a lot of complaints about Hugo too -- perphaps it is because it's a rather normal name in here (pronounced uh-go in here, though) and that I know several people named like that (one of them a guy I liked soooo much) that I don't really mind it. I prefer the Spanish pronuntiation, but that's all.)

- The epilogue. Granted, not the best epilogue ever and it rather doesn't fit with the tone of the rest of the book, it's too happy, but let's not forget that it is a kid's book, and it was only fitting that it had a happy ending. So yeah, I'd prefered it if it'd been a bit less fanfic-tastic, but I don't mind it all that much, and really, what matters to me is, the Trio is still together, still best friends, and more than that, they're family now, all of them, and it just makes me incredibly happy. I don't have anything against Ginny, but I do have to admit that her being Harry's free ticket into family bliss was the greatest reason on me not minding Harry/Ginny. Er, yes, I am aware it sounds rotten of me, but I love the Trio best and foremost, they and the Marauders, and if the latter couldn't find happiness in the end, then by God but the Trio is.

So, they still love each other, and that's all that matters. ♥ ♥

Also, and I know no one will care right now but no matter, I've made my peace with OotP. I truly liked it this time around, it's quite complex and creepy.
Music:: Carl Barat and Pete Doherty - A Day in the Life
There are 7 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
 
posted by [identity profile] schwarzbrille.livejournal.com at 09:31pm on 22/07/2007
I liked Dumbledore's backstory and him and Grindelwald are so very OTP.

Uh, YES. I've got so many plot bunnies from this I don't even know what to do with them. X3
 
posted by [identity profile] nekare.livejournal.com at 11:10pm on 22/07/2007
Ooooh, fic, fic! I do miss your writing. And what could be better for a return that hot 'best friends turned mortal enemies', huh?
 
posted by [identity profile] slowtuesdays.livejournal.com at 12:40am on 23/07/2007
I'm pretty much saying YES to all your points! Neville kicking ass, especially! And OMG, I completely forgot about McGonagall kicking ass with desks. Everything about her is awesome! And the Marauders ... sigh. That last scene when Harry had the stone -- that hurt so very very much.

I can't wait for the fic that's going to start rolling in!
 
posted by [identity profile] thejadedflames.livejournal.com at 10:46pm on 23/07/2007
Awesome review! I agree with most of your points! Especially about Remus and Neville and Luna. :D
 
posted by [identity profile] onadancefloor.livejournal.com at 03:06am on 24/07/2007
I thought the first chapter was great, but what I liked the most was Lucius's peacock, it was phenomenal.

When Ron left, I threw my book across the room, the poor thing. I was like, "No he didn't!" It was shocking and I was so sad at Ron, and then I got over it.

And I've never been much of a Hermione/Ron, but my god, I wanted them to get together in this book. They were sweet, I learned to understand and love Hermione.

Everyone who died made me incredibly sad, Lupin was always my favorite so when he went I lost it. I had to stop reading and collect myself, but oh Dobby was so sad too. Out of everyone, I thought Fred's death was incredibly unnecessary, I didn't see the point of killing him off, especially when he has a twin, what will George do now?

I wish the epilogue hadn't been so cheesy, and I also wished we had more information about everyone else. I wanted to know what happened to Luna, to Dean, basically everyone. Also, what the hell did Harry do? Aside from getting married? My life would have been complete if he became the next DADA professor.
ext_18566: (h/d quidditch)
posted by [identity profile] voldything.livejournal.com at 03:44am on 27/07/2007
- All of the mentions of the Marauders were, of course, pure WIN. Sirius and his muggle bikini-clad girls! Lily writing about how Harry had nearly killed the cat! The photo! *happy sigh*

Oh, man, I wanted to rip those pages and put them on my walls to stare at them all the time ♥
 
posted by [identity profile] lyras.livejournal.com at 08:53pm on 27/07/2007
he's never been the charming and saint-like person fanon has made him to be

Absolutely. I love Remus just the way he is, thanks :D.

December

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
      1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7 8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31