nekare: (Default)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] nekare at 12:52pm on 06/08/2007 under
I just finished re-reading Deathly Hallows (I know, I know, that was slow), and I'm still crying. I picked up reading today just when they get back into Hogwarts, and from then on, I cried at pretty much every single page.

The worse parts were, of course, Fred and Lupin and Tonks' deaths, and then when Harry was playing dead and everyone else were still willing to fight anyway and then when Voldemort died and when the first ones to hug Harry afterwards were Ron and Hermione, but mostly, I cried so, so hard during The Forest Again. I could hardly read, everything was blurry.

So yes, basically, I spent two hundred pages crying. It's weird, how it didn't affect me like this on the first reading -- I cried, but certainly not as much as today. I guess I was just numb then, and I was in too much of a hurry to see how it all ended. But yes. On a second-reading, I liked it even more this time around.

I stopped reading just before the epilogue, though, because I just couldn't take such sirupy sweetness after hours of sobbing my eyes out. o_O And that's the problem with the epilogue, it's far too anticlimatic after seven hundred pages of suffering and wonderfully told angst. But oh well.
There are 14 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
 
posted by [identity profile] pourtant.livejournal.com at 06:15pm on 06/08/2007
I haven't re-read it yet, but The Forest Again was my favourite chapter - am I am masochist? Ha.
 
posted by [identity profile] pourtant.livejournal.com at 06:17pm on 06/08/2007
*I'm also a masochist who can't type.
 
posted by [identity profile] nekare.livejournal.com at 07:55pm on 06/08/2007
Haha, maybe. :) But it's one of the best chapters of the seven books, so it's easily forgiven. *g*
 
posted by [identity profile] sunshineclouds.livejournal.com at 07:01pm on 06/08/2007
(((((((Ale))))) ¡¡No llores!!

Yo te entiendo; aun no me animo a releerlo como se debe pero si me acuerdo cuando leí The Forest Again la primera vez y tuve que poner el separador y agarrar los pañuelos porque era de ;__________________________; y no era lagrimeo, osea estaba llorando en serio. Cuando mi hermana me devuelva mi libro también lo voy a releer con mucha calma
sin el epílogo
, claro.
 
posted by [identity profile] nekare.livejournal.com at 07:58pm on 06/08/2007
Yo hasta eso casi no lloré en esa parte -- digo, me imagino que se me salió una que otra lagrimita, pero no se comparó a como lloré con Dobby. Y ahora en serio deje el cojincito en donde estaba recargada todo mojado. ;___; La idea de el pobrecito de Harry llendo a su muerte con sus papás y Sirius y Remus acompañandolo... Dios, es pura genialidad. Y él diciendo 'I'm about to die' para abrir la snitch... *sniff*

Jaja, si, no me molesta tanto el epílogo como al resto de la humanidad, me agrada saber que tuvieron su final feliz, pero en serio que no queda con el resto del libro.
ext_41195: ([hp] moony & padfoot reunited)
posted by [identity profile] crooked.livejournal.com at 07:24pm on 06/08/2007
you know, that's just it. you hit the nail on the head with that. i know that epilogue was meant to show that Harry & Co. got their happily ever after in the end. but it's just a bit jarring after, like you said, all those chapters of stuff that makes you want to cry your face off. i get what JKR was going for but it just felt too weird, like it wasn't part of that same book.

lashdfas The Forest Again. ;_; i think that might be my very favorite part from all seven books. omg, Ale, by the time James says "Until the very end." i am such an embarrassing mess of stupid sobbing girl. that whole scene was just so ridiculous. i love it so much.

dammit, i feel the need to get teary now just thinking about it. D:
 
posted by [identity profile] nekare.livejournal.com at 08:06pm on 06/08/2007
Exactly, that and the fact that JKR has really grown as a writer in these 17 years, and it just feels incredibly weaker than the rest of the book. I wouldn't have minded if the book had ended right before the epiologue, actually - sure, people would've then bitched about it being too open and not knowing Harry's kids' stupid names (because in my experience, people are always just looking for an excuse to bitch), but hey, interviews are our friends. I, for one, loved whatever tidbits of information she's already given out.

My favorite favoritest scene is still when they're all in the Shack in PoA, but yes, The Forest Again is really high up there too, it's just wonderful. Between all the ghosts going with him to his death and Harry whispering 'I'm about to die' to the snitch, oh boy, but my heart almost can't take it. ;___; Too beautiful, and I really don't get how could people be all 'OMG IT SUCKS IT SOUNDS LIKE A FANFIC' while they didn't know if the leak was, in fact, book 7 or not. Pfft, I say, like any of us could've written that. Sure, lots of people could've written it better in terms of style, but the plot? No way.

I KNOW, OMG. I felt like crying everytime Remus or Fred were onscreen when I re-watched OotP, and then made a sad face everytime I read their names while I was re-reading DH. *cries some more*
ext_41195: ([hp] the artful question)
posted by [identity profile] crooked.livejournal.com at 05:39am on 10/08/2007
i agree that the ending of the book prior to the epilogue would have been fine. i think i could have possibly lived a full and rich life never knowing that Albus Severus and Scorpius existed. [ahahaha AS/S. i must ask, Ale, do you ship ASS? :P] and just like you said it's not as if JKR would never have given us the info at some later date. hell, she'd considering an HP Encyclopedia already so it wouldn't have been so bad to end it there.

ooh yeah the Shack scene is all sorts of AWESOME! that is definitely up there in my top favorites. sdkjsdkj when he said that to the snitch i was all *CHOKE UP* and then it just really hit me when those godddamn lovable Maruaders showed up. sigh. i am too attached to those bastards. i've seen some people saying that it was a failure and it sucked as a series end and all that just makes me scratch my head. it was more than i expected it to be and now i have to go read about Sirius' room and get all sniffle-y over how awesome he must have been. XD

OMG FRED. now, i was expecting Remus to die. and maybe the mwpp fangirl in me was all "IF HE DIES HE CAN HANG OUT WITH HIS BOYS AND MAKE OUT WITH SIRIUS AGAIN!! :D" so that made it easier to accept. [i know, i am a dork.] but i didn't see Fred's death coming at all. i thought the dead!Weasley would be Percy or maybe Charlie. just... not Fred. D:
 
posted by [identity profile] nekare.livejournal.com at 12:52am on 12/08/2007
WHO DOESN'T SHIP ASS? IT'S TOO FINE A NAME TO NOT SHIP IT. Although I actually like Teddy/James better but shhhh *g*. Mmm, the encylclopedia is going to be soooo much fun!

I really don't get how people didn't like it. Sure, it wasn't perfect, but it was thrilling and awesome and interesting and much, much better written than the first books, so.

Yeah, I wasn't THAT surprised about Remus dying, but FRED. NOES. I was betting on either Percy or Bill (or even Charlie) to die, but certainly not one of the twins. *sniffle* And Hagrid. I honestly thought he wouldn't live through it. o_O
ext_41195: (Default)
posted by [identity profile] crooked.livejournal.com at 09:32am on 12/08/2007
ASS IS THE NEW BLACK. i dunno, it sounded good at the time. :| yesss i like Teddy/James better too. actually, i could give a flying fuck about ASS because i can't help but picture a H/D clone. it really is! i can't wait to see if Sirius ever gets a canon birthday. I NEED TO KNOW THESE THINGS.

it was a good, satisfying ending to me. like you said, not perfect but still damn good and entertaining! with such anticipation built up over the years, i can see some disappointment but to outright be all 'i hated it!!1!' i just don't get it. :\

it was bad enough when George lost a friggin' ear; did he have to lose his other half?! poor Fred. D: and then she said in an interview that George named his firstborn Fred and i was all kahjdklas AWWW ;__; so yeah. and i totally thought Hagrid was a goner too. that surprised me.
 
posted by [identity profile] swedish15.livejournal.com at 08:09pm on 06/08/2007
Best scene imo? Ron/Hermione, about house elves and freedom. Good alternatbe would be A. Longbottom's "Naturally."
Epilogue? Nice, but overly sugary, and the names. OMFGWTFTHENAMES!

Worst scene? Can't remember; but probably somewhere along the desertion. Or so. BTW? Can somebody please explain to me why nobody killed that evil pink toad Umbridge of? There was enough time to simply put a 9mm bullet in her head. Why did nobody do this? WHY?
 
posted by [identity profile] nekare.livejournal.com at 08:58pm on 06/08/2007
Oh, I loved that! Ron was just incredible in this book, and the 'let's free the house-elves!' was a wonderful detail. And I agree with that one as well, Neville was awesome throughout this one, and hearing his Gran actually acknowledging was touching.

Oh man, I do hope she'll rot away in Azkaban. She's a wonderful villian, but she's still a despicable woman.
 
posted by [identity profile] swedish15.livejournal.com at 09:06pm on 06/08/2007
Let's be honest - she won't. Potterverse has a longstanding tradition with villains getting out of prison faster than you can blink and innocent people staying there till the end of time.
Okay, okay, you could point out Bellatrix Lestrange, but otherwise?

No, no, Umbridge may be ruined, but she'll land on her feet - that terrible, terrible Imperius. Oh, and that vile, vile woman had threatened to do quite unspeakable things to the children if she didn't cooperate. *Sigh*. Yes, of course, she made some mistakes, but *insert giggle here* who wouldn't have, under such dreadful circumstances? Really, she was quite rational, and of course she hoped everything would work out. And for the blood quill? Oh, but it was Ministry policy, and she only followed orders. You cannot blame a poor, innocent woman for believing in her betters, can you? After all, we all should believe in our betters, right?
 
posted by [identity profile] swedish15.livejournal.com at 09:11pm on 06/08/2007
Ah, btw, sorry, I'm a little bit down, and on a SH-trip. And I suddenly have a desire to see Umbridge in SH. Similar to Rupert Giles in Silent Hill, not sending them there would be akin to taking candy (our poor, soon-to-be-tortured characters) from a baby (a poor, Giles-and-Umbridge-less Silent Hill.)

Pity the town.
Which is a joke most people won't get, I realize.

December

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
      1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7 8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31